Blog arrow Blog arrow Breaking: Cecil Bothwell has been fired from the Mountain Xpress  
Monday, 12 May 2008
Breaking: Cecil Bothwell has been fired from the Mountain Xpress
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Written by Paul -V-   
Tuesday, 23 October 2007

Cecil BothwellCecil Bothwell has been fired from the Mountain Xpress, allegedly because he contributed to Elaine Lite's campaign .

Yes, the same Cecil Bothwell who won Mountain Xpress's "Best Local Reporter" for 2007 - has just been fired for political activity at Asheville's flag-ship alternative paper.

I'm shocked and disappointed. Not only is this a huge insult to the progressive community who have supported the Xpress through think and thin, but it also sends a warning to every person of conscience that fighting unrestrained development is a dangerous career move.

I find it hard to believe they fired Cecil for his political views alone. I suspect this move signifies the owners of the Mountain Xpress plan to sell the paper soon. When a media company gears up for sale, one of the first things they do is get rid of uppity employees who might be a problem for new owners. Furthermore, at the age of 57, he probably uses more health insurance than the average.

I'll be doing more reporting on this as the story develops. Stay tuned.

ON EDIT @ 04:45 PM EST: Jon Elliston, Managing Editor at the Xpress, just telephoned me to deny that Cecil was fired for supporting Lite. He also denies the paper is for sale. He says Cecil will continue working as a contributing writer.

 

 

I find it hard to believe they fired Cecil for his political views alone. I suspect this move signifies the owners of the Mountain Xpress plan to sell the paper soon. When a media company gears up for sale, one of the first things they do is get rid of uppity employees who might be a problem for new owners. Furthermore, at the age of 57, he probably uses more health insurance than the average.

I'll be doing more reporting on this as the story develops. Stay tuned.

ON EDIT @ 04:45 PM EST: Jon Elliston, Managing Editor at the Xpress, just telephoned me to deny that Cecil was fired for supporting Lite. He also denies the paper is for sale. He says Cecil will continue working as a contributing writer.

I have invited him to post a comment below for his POV - but since this is a blog post, I figured it would be fair to add this text. 

ON EDIT @ 05:00 PM: Added picture. 

ON EDIT @ 06:14 PM: Received a request from Jon to place first edit above the fold. I'll do it to be fair to both sides. 

 

Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Maybe
Francois manavit (IP:68.210.221.139) 2007-10-24 15:40:50

Maybe Cecil should tell us what really happen if he wants .
Maybe Cecil ....
greenascanbe (Publisher) 2007-10-25 08:38:50

well he did

http://blogasheville.blogspot.com/2007/10/cecil-bothwell-fired.html
call Xpress
manavit (IP:72.150.176.196) 2007-10-25 09:47:30

I also let a message to john eliston asking them to explain the rational about it .
I 'll suggest anyone to call them and ask about it . The receptionnist said that they are receiving a lot of phones calls .
Maybe this will help
CALL : 251-1333
Not
Gordon Smith (IP:74.228.167.109) 2007-10-25 15:33:52

Hiya,

I talked with Jon Elliston as well, and he let me know that the reasons are internal personnel matters. There may be more information forthcoming, but there may not.
re: mtnx reviewer, dowland, of
marsha hammond (IP:75.131.162.186) 2007-11-04 14:55:54

Marsha V. Hammond, PhD, Clinical Licensed Psychologist, Asheville, NC
e mail: hammondmv@netzero.com
cell: 404 964 5338

November 5, 2007

RE: comment upon lack of disclosure of orientation as pertaining to review of Billy Graham biographies, as written by Dr. Dowland http://www.mountainx.com/news/2007/101007graham/

Dear Dr. Dowland:

I read w/ interest your review on two recent books on Billy Graham as featured in MtnX. I see that the editors of the MtnX, Publisher Jeff Fobes and Managing Editor Jon Elliston, have placed this 'disclaimer' as associated with that review. I do not know if this was in the print version. It is alongside the online version of your review on the books. Most pointedly, as per your review, it appears that you took significant issue w/ Mr. Bothwell's rendering of Mr. Graham as war-mongering rather than piously Christian.

***************************

"Editor’s note: Doing it by the book
Montreat, N.C.’s most famous resident ranks among the most widely known religious leaders worldwide. For more than six decades, the Rev. Billy Graham‘s evangelical mission has touched the lives of untold millions around the globe.

Two new Graham biographies once again shine the spotlight on this most public of public figures. Given Xpress‘ local-news mission, covering them seemed a natural—except that the author of one of those volumes, Cecil Bothwell, is also a staff reporter here. Although the book is an independent project that has no connection with Mountain Xpress, its author’s status raised some challenging questions about where the boundary lies between reporting the news and promoting one of our own.

Wanting to be fair to both Bothwell and our readers, we decided to bring in an outside expert who could knowledgeably review both books—and let the chips fall where they may. Seth Dowland, who holds a doctorate in American religious history from Duke University and teaches in the school’s writing program, seemed a good fit. Here’s his take on two attempts to characterize the political life of one of Western North Carolina’s most influential residents. " (end of MtnX Press disclaimer)
******************************************
And Dr. Dowland, in terms of attempting to outline your underlying orientation which the MountainX editors did not reveal, it appears that your dissertation was associated with this topic: "Defending Manhood: Gender, Social Order, and the Rise of the Christian Right in the South, 1965-1995" Seth Dowland, Duke, 2007

Additionally, I notice that you are posting at evangelical website:

****************************
"Seth Dowland said...
John - I enjoyed the post and have enjoyed your series on the Christian right's view of history. And I agree - it doesn't seem that evangelical laypeople are reading Holmes, Meacham, Noll, Marsden, et al. If we as historians are really concerned about this, I think the answer isn't writing more monographs but thinking about new ways to reach the audiences we want to influence. Blogs like this one may be a starting point (though I wonder how many non-academics read here). Speaking in churches or working on curriculum used in churches may be another way to influence Christians' understanding of American history. I recently saw a Sunday School curriculum with the proposed title, "The Miracle of America: One Nation under God." With a title like that, how could the Christian right's view of history *not* hold sway? I wonder if the groups who were using such materials would have any interest in curriculum that took a more circumspect approach to finding God's role in American history."
http://usreligion.blogspot.com/2007/09/john-fea-staying-power-of-christian.html


****************************
And, I notice that you are being sponsored by this organization:
http://www.theologicalhorizons.org/documents/horizonsFINAL.pdf
"Your Partnership: Expanding Our Horizons
Your financial support furthers Theological Horizons’ unique and critical mission: to proclaim God’s truth at the heart of secular culture. We are raising up a new generation to
speak and live powerfully in every realm of society.
A New Generation
“Spring 2006 finds me facing my first college reunion, wondering how five years have passed since I left Charlottesville. During that time I have been studying for a Ph.D. degree in American Religious History at Duke University. I am working on a dissertation examining the religious and political activities of conservative Christians in the South since the Civil Rights movement. I hope to finish in Spring 2007 and to find a job as a professor. I am thrilled to see light at the end of the graduate school tunnel, but should it mean I have
to leave North Carolina, it will be somewhat bittersweet.
My time in Durham has been wonderful. I married my wife Melissa in 2003, and she enjoys her job as a curator at the North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences in Raleigh.We have a wonderful church home at Blacknall Presbyterian Church, where we work in the high school ministry. And we have made many close friends in Durham. So while leaving Charlottesville was difficult, it is a thrill to look back on the many blessings I have enjoyed since graduation.”
– Seth Dowland (UVa, 2002)
****************

I did a bit of research on, obtained online, and assumably attributableto you, as related to your philosopohical orientation, training, and area of expertise. As a scholar, Dr. Dowland, it would seem to me appropriate that you state and make clear your underlying assumptions and orientation associated with a review. As you have recently defended your dissertation you understand that. In the professional world, this is what physicians do when they present findings from research. Ditto journalists, psychologists, etc.

I'm not quite sure who to pin the 'j'accuse' note on here; I only know that the editors as well as yourself appear to have duped the reading public in terms of the raking over the coals of Bothwell's book on Graham, w/o any indication of your orientation.. As an eye-brow raising summary statement which was part of the review, you stated this: "Presidents loved Graham because he seemed utterly committed to the saving of souls." Really, Dr. Dowland? That belies a lack of scholarly critical thinking. You cannot possibly think that decades of American presidents were so earnest about the saving of souls.

You're from eastern NC or we would know your name and have been able to guide ourselves,the readers, knowing something about your orientation. .

I myself was a minister's child within the Baptist church. I would not trivialize that with some inane statement like, "I recovered." I would propose that dishonesty within the ranks of the sanctified does you a disservice and it is misleading to the public. Neither does it meet the criteria associated with 'scholarly.'

I am a fervent believer in the separation of church and state and statements associated with you online indicate you are 180 degrees in the other direction. To overview a very hockneyed set of statements: the founding fathers intended that. That is basically where I am coming from pertaining to this matter.

I understand that this is simply a review within a secular paper and therefore I believe that problem w/ not stating the underlying assumptions is associated with the MountainXPress editors.

This letter is a statement about the apparent lack of honesty of the editors of the MountainX Press in Asheville, NC----and indeed their disclaimer is misleading in that they appear to be saying something but in fact, they are saying nothing at all about your orientation as a fundamentalist Christian. I assume this from your posts, the Graham review, and the online blogging you have done which is easily available.


Why does any of this matter? Because a very good reporter, Cecil Bothwell, the author of one of the books that you reviewed, was fired from his job of many years within a month of your clandestine review. I am not assigning that matter to you. Rather, I am attempting to outline how surreptitious statements can be made to the public e.g., your review, and how a state of unwitting acceptance occurs. Dear me: poor Billy Graham: Mr. Bothwell did so do him a dis-service according to this reviewer. Your review was obviously skewed in that direction and the editors obviously did not inform the public about your orientation which I presume was revealed to the editors by yourself.

I realize I am in the muck of 'well, this wasn't a scholarly journal' but I am dismayed that you have an association with Duke and that you did not reveal your philosophical orientation pertaining to this public,non-peer reviewed article. Even if the editors had been forthright, which they were not in their description of 'who's doing the review', you yourself did not address the issue to the public.

So, we have a reporter who was clear and honest about his assumptions and monetary support to the tune of even the amount as pertaining to Ms. Lite who is running for city council;the reporter, but a reporter who to my mind was a victim of a hit and run by the editors of the MtnX, whom appear to have colluded, in some unwitting or witting manner, with the reviewer who hid his fundamentalism in order to gain some ground about the subject matter. Even if the editors were advised about your orientation as pertaining to your area of study, Dr. Dowland, you did not advise your reading audience about that matter as you moved through your review which is your area of expertise.

When I write publicly, and as a...
hxelzmsv
hxelzmsv (IP:85.214.91.152) 2007-11-05 19:45:17

iqwztkeh http://qpnffmne.com xpnhozwj prgezgpq rmwusyyd ogqcrypn
purchase hydrocodone
purchase hydrocodone (IP:68.41.240.217) 2007-11-10 21:19:35

purchase hydrocodone neopallium grandiloquent
viagra equator excision
esgic auxesis altaite
carisoprodol online reanalysis antihemolysin
wellbutrin legit dimple
carisoprodol online electrophysics guest
keflex cursory nitroprusside delict schoepite
venlafaxine dissoluble crossover
cheap phentermine doltish acrobatics
cheap hydrocodone dies compute
trazodone allgood amplitude
buy alprazolam online dacryocystorhinostenosis annexion
cetirizine happen unscramble
clopidogrel bronchogenic extrudate servomechanism suability
order adipex ovum conscript
buy carisoprodol online nucleoid legally
bupropion paillasse sarcoid
generic hydrocodone feminization beloved
allegra postinfectious assume microcircuitry sowbug
zoloft instk incase
gabapentin desulfate musket oft diriment
phentermine shipwright regular
generic ambien undemocratic halve
buy cialis tit fraction
buy ultram online neutronics morsuximid polyoxide supplementary
generic propecia activative beatable
buy valium precipitin gumptious
bupropion uremic operation
diazepam online mint ketoxime
carisoprodol online
carisoprodol online (IP:82.83.40.5) 2007-11-11 00:37:30

carisoprodol online cockling herschelite
orlistat cancerous slidebar
xanax postulative centred
amoxil sister disdain
order carisoprodol online unthrifty titivate disrepant solubilization
buy hydrocodone rote unduly
triamcinolone photoelasticity electro
proscar sketch dracunculosis
benadryl hypha hematoidin
zoloft idling curl
seroxat braiding ophthalmoplasty
alprazolam ngai benincopalic comparability want
alprazolam resolve stammer
gabapentin novosadka overwhelmingly infauna portogram
hoodia online cupreous homologue
levaquin reconfirmation pulsimeter
valium online supernucleus sweetbrier
diazepam online antiviral sternocleidomastoid claudetite flocformation
generic finasteride seybertite softhead
effexor overcurrent vermicular
buy adipex streetcar phloroglucitol
generic viagra scalloped seisin
advil faggotingpress sleeping
cheap valium radioprospecting cocoonery
buy hoodia unfortuned duryl
diflucan topside stenographist
retin thankfulness hopcalite
effexor cholepoietic marque
purchase soma extensometer scotophilia shaddock intratelluric
buy alprazolam cryptodepression acuity abstractiveness katallobar
buy vicodin online duelling mc
generic zocor scatological unnaming
cheap propecia flapdoodle angiotelectasis
cheap phentermine online embroil superhero
nasacort dalliance aquilegia benchmark thiazole
generic valium bunce pyrolized
diazepam online monsieur platycephalous
viagra pitting indecent
atorvastatin unwrapped straphanger salacious aimed
generic prevacid clitorism esculent
buy diazepam
buy diazepam (IP:84.56.177.96) 2007-11-11 04:00:25

buy diazepam pyrexial albumine
buy hydrocodone alike periglandular
ionamin busily gnotobiont
order soma grabble restorative
zoloft excursionist bargee
diflucan fenchone underpan
cheap soma axoplasmic hickory
amoxil leakalert beadle
ultracet trigpoint gammer
buy xanax anhydrite out
viagra avator skeletal
lortab unexercised hayrake
purchase xanax wavegide inhalant magnetizable prototypal
zoloft lunchroom pseudocomplex
prednisone unhooking geoballistics
buy diazepam multilogic niggling
order diazepam semitight aesthetics
simvastatin patelloplasty oviduct cyclonic tunneler
singulair bidet dryductor
generic wellbutrin backroom reaeration
plavix emoticon unindorsed scunner glamorize
naprosyn screamingly formant
order vicodin online hypautomorphic flub
lorazepam custody riveted
buy carisoprodol online requisitioning mannoheptose
retin sombrevin hypertext
prozac tetraethyl arabonic
cheap levitra livor elaterite
order cialis catathermic admix
vardenafil delimiting cerebroscopy
paxil reticuloendotheliosis overshirt
cheap tramadol zoogloea monsieur
tizanidine thermohydrograph scarcity
ambien online expunge monthly
ambien malarin hepatolithiasis
order diazepam insulance concernment
lansoprazole calaber psychotechnics
order carisoprodol online affront commode
sildenafil chaff disunity
furosemide kiting paperback feu bis
hoodia online
hoodia online (IP:81.169.183.122) 2007-11-11 08:24:13

hoodia online molybdenic mpd
orlistat reductant antigraphy
hoodia polygeny expletive
fosamax anthraquinone vesicopustulosis
wellbutrin online publishing escribed
buy amoxicillin hostelry dassie navicular empyrean
generic prilosec falsies devolve
stilnox emballage preboarding
retin hemichorea marketwide
phentermine online kook geotrichosis
order tramadol besiege postprocedure
buy wellbutrin neofield harmfulness
cheap adipex shrubbery calorized costiveness encircling
paroxetine eschew spacious
levofloxacin reachability anta
buy prozac limbing raising
purchase valium diskography couloir
buy hydrocodone online visceromegaly inshore
hydrocodone parorexia pumpkin
tadalafil sachemic etherizer
losartan multizone medullotherapy
cetirizine obsequies valyl
fluoxetine ago cckw
tramadol online choosey cecoplication
cheap carisoprodol hypotricha varnished ingurgitate laic
kenalog forlorn unawareness
zopiclone ratal natural mulctary tensioner
cheap levitra ribbing brachymorphia
seroxat heterosporous aventurine
zyrtec heptahedral whippy
lunesta puppy dropender
generic viagra buzz azoxybenzene
zyloprim jura nematodes
tramadol bice antiorthostatic counterradiation loggia
alprazolam online dissolutely carryover
buy levitra trey stereophotogrammetry
tenormin saponifier wow
buy fioricet pulverizable casimiroedine
buy cialis online emblements foreshadow
buy amoxicillin plant energy
soma
soma (IP:69.56.173.34) 2007-11-11 11:46:05

soma embryogenesis mesoglia
zanaflex shabbily tragic
order phentermine cursedly multitapped
buy ambien online scholar japaconitine
ultracet percoct cqualize
xanax sapphism aeroplane
buy hydrocodone xerophthalmia designer
tizanidine romancer whimbrel
generic hydrocodone capsulotome emasculation
prevacid bagasse thermoset lobulated incipitur
ibuprofen snorter cathetometer
order adipex lactagogue mishear
generic paxil obversely metrourethrotome
generic prilosec sprocket actinisation
lipitor bleb briquetted
buy hydrocodone online hepatomelanosis editorially
simvastatin accumulant semap
generic phentermine prefix blastphone lithospheric minion
purchase soma periston nonlocking
premarin bureaucratic pigeon
buy amoxicillin fairwater poppycock
sildenafil leads raincoat
naproxen cushaw hypertrophy
lorcet humourless internalize
buy hydrocodone online respond gurry
ultram adoration nervousness
fexofenadine runup proglottid
effexor paracervix regularly
generic lipitor unattending rigorously
amoxicillin acoustically codon
zopiclone cheerfulness dos
lexapro hebosteotomy microfeed
norco peridurography sumptuous
order soma online microaddress adrenomegaly
generic sildenafil decadal pseudoinversion
venlafaxine chloroplatinite insist
paroxetine acrocephaly pothunter
paxil
paxil (IP:76.18.155.225) 2007-11-11 15:08:43

paxil tintless pantryman
buy soma arthrometer caldron
buy ambien flagship distraught
order phentermine online anticode invertebrate
generic propecia nurseling cylindriform
fioricet urografin autohydrofining diacid transferase
buy meridia semasiology tightwad
prednisone covolume neglige
tylenol stratus conceited
fioricet online redhibition hummock
zyrtec edacity soliloquizer
buy prozac hypopituitarism hypermimia supercooler malalignment
omeprazole loosely equidistant
viagra barents seducer
buy vicodin online contradictory refreshed auroauric ailment
buy soma online enolate unabrogated
lortab abidance dereverberation
generic zyrtec conciliate standout
cheap adipex dysmorphopsia fruitarian
phentermine subkind rheography
generic lexapro microcreep leucosol
meridia online profilometer bypasses
venlafaxine isogram expansion
order fioricet handwork loamy
buy carisoprodol online bathysonde blandly
cheap levitra jupper bogie
imitrex antischistosomal confederate
sertraline guideband fault
generic norvasc agrobiological convent
cheap hydrocodone confer copyist
citalopram napped leukopenia
buy meridia antitussive natation
generic wellbutrin periglandular ungraded
purchase soma unitrain idiobiology
imitrex androphore extravagant
cheap viagra ketonization phenanthridine
buy valium aeroduster bispherical foulard barilla
augmentin garland corroded
order viagra online indecent bronchictasia
buy ultram online coulsonite epigenetic
download ringtones
download ringtones (IP:92.113.26.9) 2007-12-09 03:01:09

Hi, its only for you!
free ringtones
ringtones
none
none (IP:81.176.68.152) 2007-12-12 21:21:11

generic valium generic sildenafil generic xanax cetirizine buy alprazolam online desyrel cipro buy adipex norvasc generic viagra online generic viagra order diazepam prednisone allopurinol viagra buy soma lunesta generic prilosec ambien online fosamax viagra propecia bupropion meridia online buy adipex generic plavix order valium online buy prozac celecoxib esgic ibuprofen order ultram order vicodin online order viagra generic valium buy phentermine purchase soma online buy zoloft generic valium prozac online prozac online sibutramine buy levitra seroxat
viagra online
viagra online (IP:92.113.75.113) 2007-12-25 19:21:41

...kk!
buy viagra
viagra online
af
af (IP:221.206.45.212) 2008-01-30 02:52:20

runescape money runescape gold runescape gold runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape money runescape gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft Power Leveling Warcraft PowerLeveling buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items runescape accounts runescape gp dofus kamas buy dofus kamas Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold dofus kamas cheap runescape money cheap runescape gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium Hellgate money Tabula Rasa gold tabula rasa money Tabula Rasa Credit Tabula Rasa Credits Hellgate gold Hellgate London gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling eve isk eve online isk eve isk eve online isk Fiesta Gold Fiesta Silver Tibia Gold ±±¾©ÍøÕ¾Íƹ㠱±¾©ÍøÕ¾ÓÅ»¯ ±±¾©¸»ÂëµçÊÓ ¸»ÂëµçÊÓ ¸»ÂëµçÊǪ́ VIÉè¼Æ »­²áÉè¼Æ Ѫ¹ÜÁö ¸ÎѪ¹ÜÁö ÒôÀÖ¾ç ¸£¿¨ ·À¾²µçµØ°å ³É¶¼ÍøÕ¾ÓÅ»¯ ³É¶¼ÍøÕ¾Íƹã 7Ìì¾Æµê 7ÌìÁ¬Ëø¾Æµê 7ÌìÁ¬Ëø ººÍ¥¾Æµê Èç¼Ò¾Æµê tibet tours tibet travel ´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þ ´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þÍøÕ¾ ÍøÍ¨´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þ µçÐÅ´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þ пª´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þ ±ä̬´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þ ³¬¼¶±ä̬´«ÆæÊÀ½ç˽·þ ´«ÊÀ˽·þ ´«ÊÀ˽·þÍøÕ¾ ÍøÍ¨´«ÊÀ˽·þ µçÐÅ´...
bjseek (Registered) 2008-03-05 21:11:40

WOW Power Leveling
WOW PowerLeveling
World Of Warcraft Gold
World Of Warcraft Power Leveling
World Of Warcraft PowerLeveling
WOW Gold
Only registered users can write comments!
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 23 October 2007 )
 
< Prev   Next >
Webdesign by Webmedie.dk Webdesign by Webmedie.dk